Mania Grade: A+
9 Comments | Add
Rate & Share:
Related Links:
Info:
- TV Series: Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
- Episode: Mr. Ferguson is Ill Today
- Starring: Lena Headey, Summer Glau, Thomas Dekker, Brian Austin Green, Richard T. Jones, Garret Dillahunt, Leven Rambin,
- Written By: Daniel T. Thomsen
- Directed By: Michael Nankin
- Network: Fox
- Series: Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
TERMINATOR: THE SARAH CONNOR CHRONICLES: Mr. Ferguson is Ill Today
The Big Showdown Spaghetti Western Style By
Stephen Lackey
November 13, 2008
Cameron (Summer Glau) in "Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles: Mr. Ferguson is Ill Today"(2008).
© Fox TV
There was once a little film called Rashomon. That film told the same story several times throughout its running time via the perspective of each of the main characters. Since that movie, this style of storytelling has been used over and over again by various television series and movies. Done right this type of storytelling can truly offer a unique experience. The trick is not to simply show the story over and over again from different angles. The real magic happens when the same familiar story is told from the perspective of the character plus tweaking it for the personality and behind the scenes decision making of each character. This episode of The Sarah Connor Chronicles hits those magical beats perfectly.
The story here isn’t just retold from different perspectives, it progresses through different perspectives. For example, the first act of the episode is Sarah’s Story; the second act is Cameron’s Story picking up at about the halfway point of Sarah’s Story and so on from the perspectives of all the main characters including Cromartie’s. Sarah has been beaten up emotionally by John for the past couple of episodes and she keeps taking it from him because she appreciates the loneliness of his struggle to prepare for the future and maintain his human-ness at the same time. The episode starts with that conflict between her and John over Riley coming around. Sarah and Cameron both believe that Riley will end up dead if she keeps coming around and John does too but he’s to selfish to give Riley up. The conflict between Sarah and John comes to a head when she tells him that if Riley keeps coming around she’ll end up shot and counters by asking if she plans on shooting Riley. It’s an intensely human conflict, standing in stark comparison to the battle they constantly flight against the inhuman machines. It’s well played and part of the underpinnings of this show below the action and sci-fi, and it makes the show relatable and gripping. It worked best in Terminator 2 and it continues to work in this series.
The focus of this episode is the promise from the ads of a death this week. It could easily have been Riley but that just would have been too predictable. In a way the death of Cromartie is a fake out, because he can just keep coming back from the future but that fact doesn’t make the episode any less exciting. The episode culminates in a massive and exciting fire fight in a church in Mexico that started with some great dialogue from Ellison. There’s an emotional breakdown from Sarah at the end of the episode that has real weight because of the pressure that she is under and the sadness that she feels for her son’s life. There’s actually an argument that could be made for this episode to have been a series finale. It’s easy to see that the producers could have planned this episode to end the show if it didn’t get picked up. It’s not a complete ending but it’s a strong stopping point. Thankfully, there’s at least the rest of this season to further tell Sarah’s story.
A ? You've got to be effing kidding me. This was by far the best episode of the season so far. By a very very wide margin. But seriously, this is as good as it gets? I don't think so. It was great to have a break from Shirley Manson's horrible acting and it was great to actually see a couple of action scenes for a change. They even cut the stupid opening from this one. It feels like they're actually trying. But A ? I do like the same story from different perspectives approach but this works best when there are sufficient details that are missing from one story which will be filled in by the others. The writers of this show just don't have the chops to pull that off. The Simpsons did a pretty great job with one of these several years ago but then the writers of the Simpsons are in a whole different league from these jokers. Also, playing some Mexican song during a shootout in a church is a pretty hokey cliche and they couldn't even get a decent sounding song. This episode was a solid B, B . A vast improvement over the C-, D grades this season deserves so far.