High Def Revue


Three free HD DVDs from Toshiba, and "Click" on Blu-ray.

By: John Sinnott
Date: Sunday, October 29, 2006

Three free HD DVDs with every Toshiba player: Thinking about buying a HD DVD player for Christmas? Wait until November 1st if you want to score three free HD discs. Toshiba has announced that it will give away three discs with every player sold. Buyers will get to chose one HD DVD from each of three studios. The choices are:

Universal:

APOLLO 13

THE CHRONICLES OF RIDDICK (Unrated)

THE RUNDOWN

SEABISCUIT

U-571

Warner:

BLAZING SADDLES

CASABLANCA

CONSTANTINE

THE DUKES OF HAZZARD (Unrated)

THE PERFECT STORM

Paramount:

FOUR BROTHER

LARA CROFT: TOMB RAIDER

SKY CAPTAIN AND THE WORLD OF TOMORROW

U2: RATTLE AND HUM

The offer is good for players purchased between November 1st, 2006 and February 28, 2007. You can print out an order form from the HD DVD consortium’s web site here.

Sony delays their Blu-ray player…again: It has been said that Sony doesn’t know how to successfully launch a new product. After the mini-cd, the UMD fiasco for the PSP (which hasn’t been doing very well itself), not to mention Beta video tapes, some people have no faith in the Japanese multinational corporation. Adding another piece of evidence in favor of that theory is the fact that Sony itself, the company behind the Blu-ray technology, hasn’t released a player yet. Originally scheduled for May of 2006, the Sony player has been pushed back further and further. October 17th was a date bandied about for a while, but that’s come and gone. Now Sony says sometime in early December. We’ll let you know as soon as they push that date back again.

SMALLVILLE flies onto HD DVD: The adventures of the teen-age Clark Kent will be heading to HD DVD on November 28th when Season 5 of SMALLVILLE is released. If this date holds, SMALLVILLE will be the first TV series to get a high definition release. (THE SOPRANOS was scheduled for a November 7th release, but it has been postponed indefinitely.) Will season sets of popular TV shows have the same appeal on HD as they do on SD DVDs? Only time will tell.

Spotlight of the week:

Click on Blu-ray:

One of the advantages that the Blu-ray format has over its rival, HD DVD is a larger capacity. While HD DVDs are limited to 15GB per layer, Blu-ray discs can store 25GB worth of data on a single layer. It sounds like a solid advantage except for one thing: there were problems getting dual layer BR discs to work properly while the HD DVDs were released with two layers from the start. That effectively tilted the advantage to HD DVD (30GB per disc vs. BR's 25GB) and forced Sony to play catch-up.

Sony has caught up and released the first dual layer BD: Click. This Adam Sandler vehicle starts off as a typical goofy fantasy film, but about halfway through tosses out the humor and instead decides to pound the viewers over the head with THE MESSAGE: family is more important than work. The odd thing is that anyone who needs to hear this message will probably never see this film.

Michael Newman (Adam Sandler) is one of the head architects in a large firm in New York who designs multi-million dollar hotels and apparently makes just above minimum wage. (He drives a beat up car and can't afford to buy his kids $100 bicycles.) He's bucking to become a partner in the firm, but his boss keeps delaying the promotion while piling more work on the poor schlub. After a particularly hard day, Michael blows up while trying to get the TV and DVD player to turn on, and decides to get a universal remote. The only store he can find that's open is Bed, Bath, and Beyond, and after laying on one of their display beds for a moment while commenting on how tired he is (Holy yellow brick road Batman!) he notices a door labeled "Beyond." Entering the portal, the poor overworked architect discovers Morty (wonderfully played by Christopher Walken), an odd distracted inventor-type person who inform Michael that the have a new, top of the line universal remote that isn't even on the market yet. He gives the device to Newman, free of charge, with the cryptically obtuse warning that there are no returns.

Once home, Michael discovers that it is a universal remote, one for controlling the universe. He can pause the life, rewind to relive any time in his past, and even turn on a commentary track (narrated by James Earl Jones. As Morty says, James does a lot of voice over work.) The neatest aspect though is the fast forward button. With it Michael can jump past the boring parts of his life; dinner with the parents, rush hour traffic, and even having a head cold. How cool would that be?

The problem starts after Michael decides to fast forward until he's been granted a partnership. What he thinks will be a couple of months of toil that he'll miss turns into an entire year that he's skipped. After that the remote takes on a life of its own, fast forwarding past things that Michael does want to experience. Michael's life starts to whiz by him, he's powerless to stop it.

It's obvious from this movie that Sandler is trying to become a more serious actor. The film is neatly broken into two parts with the first being a typical Sandler film, the second an attempted drama. The beginning is funny, goofy and filled with low brow humor that makes you laugh despite yourself. People won't want to admit it, but seeing Michael pause the universe so that he can climb onto his boss' desk and fart in his face is funny. It's the later part that drags the film down.

The second half of the film it throws all of the comedy out the window and switches into 'heavy drama' mode. This section is sad, depressing, and actually not that entertaining. The exact opposite of the first half of the film. The biggest problem is that the attempts at tear jerking moments, such as when Michael replays the last time he saw his father alive, don't work at all. These will cause more people to roll their eyes than to reach for a tissue. Instead of a thoughtful gentle moment viewers get THE MESSAGE OF THE FILM pounded into their heads. He shouldn't ignore his family for the sake of his job! He should spend time with his parents while he can! Children grow up fast, so enjoy every moment! He should cherish his wife; after all she's a hottie!

Adam Sandler could possibly be a dramatic actor, but this movie doesn't prove it. Since the beginning of the film doesn't allow the viewers to really empathize and identify with Michael (it's a comedy after all), the heartfelt moments later in the film have no emotional impact.

A predictable film, we've all seen this type of movie before, it doesn't offer anything new or different. The beginning was entertaining and fun but the last half of the movie drags and is more of a downer than anything else. The message is so over-the-top and stated so many times (not to mention obvious) that it drains the fun out of the film.

Okay, the movie wasn’t great. How’s the video? After all, everyone who has been following this format war has been waiting to see how the new dual-layer Blu-ray discs will stack up. If Click is any indication, they stack up pretty well. The 1.85:1 image, while not significantly superior to other recent BDs looks very good. The first things people will notice about the disc are the bright colors that are bright and vivid and the high level of dimensionality that the film has. The level of detail is excellent, the blacks are solid, and there is no print damage (since this was shot digitally, there is no "print".)

It's not a perfect image however. There is a bit of digital noise present in scenes where one featureless color dominates the picture. It's not present at a significant level like some early BD releases, but it was present never the less. The other problem I had was with the colors. Though they are bright and solid in a few scenes it looks like they were adjusted in post-production a bit too much. This gives these scenes a bit of a plastic feel to it and the skin tones are a bit too even. Again, this is a minor problem that only affects a few scenes.

The big advantage that the 50GB BDs have is the ability to present a film, lossless audio (which this disc has), and an entire compliment of bonus features on the same disc. Sony shows off with this initial dual layer release by providing a lot of extras. There's a commentary by director Frank Coraci, producer Tim Herlihy, writer Steve Koren, and Adam Sandler. There are also seven featurettes that run about half an hour all together and explain how many of the special effects were creating including the humping dogs. The four deleted scenes weren't anything special but it is fun to see them. All in all a nice set of bonus features.

This could have been a light amusing movie, but half way through it changes from a comedy to a drama, and it's the drama part that seriously harms the film. This downer second half drains all of the fun and entertainment that the start of the movie set up. The 50GB dual layer Blu-ray disc looks and sounds good though, and the fact that it has a full compliment of bonus features is a great plus. Sandler fans will likely be disappointed in this misfire.

Upcoming High Definition Discs:

October 30, 2006

HD DVD and Blu-ray

MISSION IMPOSSIBLE – ULTIMATE MISSIONS COLLECTION

MISSION IMPOSSIBLE III

October 31, 2006

HD DVD

EXCALIBUR

V FOR VENDETTA

UNDER SEIGE

Blu-ray

THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA

THE SEARCHERS

UNDER SEIGE

UNFORGIVEN

November 07, 2006

HD DVD

NACHO LIBRE

REDS

Blu-ray

LITTLE MAN

NACHO LIBRE

REDS

November 14, 2006

HD DVD

ACCEPTED

CASABLANCA

DIGITAL VIDEO ESSENTAILS - HD DVD EDITION

FORBIDDEN PLANET

KING KONG (2005)

MUTINY ON THE BOUNTY

WATERWORLD

Blu-ray

ATL

BEHIND ENEMY LINES

BLACK HAWK DOWN

FANTASTIC FOUR

KINGDOM OF HEAVEN: DIRECTOR’S CUT

KISS OF THE DRAGON

LAST SAMURAI

LAYER CAKE

LEAGUE OF EXTRODINARY GENTLEMEN

MILLION DOLLAR BABY

OMEN

SPEED

TRANSPORTER

November 21, 2006

HD DVD

DR. SEUSS’ HOW THE GRINCH STOLE CHRISTMAS

YOU, ME, AND DUPREE

Blu-ray

ANNAPOLIS

CASANOVA

ENEMY OF THE STATE

FLIGHTPLAN

GOAL! THE DREAM BEGINS

ICE AGE: THE MELTDOWN

SKY HIGH

THE WILD

November 28, 2006

HD DVD

AN AMERICAN WEREWOLF IN LONDON

DUNE

MEET THE PARENTS

THE MUMMY (1999)

SMALLVILLE: THE COMPLETE FIFTH SEASON

SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE

SUPERMAN II: THE RICHARD DONNER CUT

SUPERMAN RETURNS

Blu-ray

SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE

SUPERMAN II: THE RICHARD DONNER CUT

SUPERMAN RETURNS

THE USUAL SUSPECTS

WINDTALKERS



More From Mania

High Def Trailer for Shyamalan's HAPPENING

High Def Update
(Saturday, July 14, 2007)
Superman II: The Donner Cut
(Sunday, December 24, 2006)
Comic Store Revue
(Monday, November 20, 2006)
High Def Promotion
(Monday, January 23, 2006)
Definitive Answers On High-Def
(Friday, October 7, 2005)
Toshiba’s HD-DVD players will do high-def only via HDMI
(Tuesday, July 12, 2005)
High-definition gaming
(Friday, February 11, 2005)

See more related content
More Content By John Sinnott
"My Hero: Season 1"
(Friday, January 19, 2007)
Brother’s Grimm
(Sunday, January 14, 2007)
"The Calamari Wrestler"
(Sunday, January 7, 2007)
Lady in the Water
(Sunday, January 7, 2007)
Sky High
(Sunday, December 31, 2006)
"Aragami: The Raging God of Battle (2002)"
(Saturday, December 30, 2006)
Superman II: The Donner Cut
(Sunday, December 24, 2006)
"Mystery Science Theater: Vol. 7"
(Saturday, December 23, 2006)
“Superman: The Movie” and troubles for Blu-ray?
(Sunday, December 17, 2006)
"Odyssey 5"
(Thursday, December 14, 2006)
Comments/Responses
1
phillipej • Oct 30, 2006, 05:55pm •
Can't afford an HD monitor. Can't afford an HD player. Unitl the prices of both devices come down, I can't believe that HD-DVD and Blu-ray sales are ever going to take off.

DarkJedi • Oct 30, 2006, 07:39pm •
Which is already on the way, Phillip. Pricing has continued to go downward in pricing ranges the past few years.

Nowdays, you can get a decent HDTV around 700 dollars at Sam's Club or Walmart. A year from now, they may be lower.

As the tv market FINALLY goes towards mandatory widescreen viewing(that's a rant of mine waiting to explode), the market of HDTV prices will continue to lower and be accessible for everyone.

It's much like VCRs to DVD. Once the market comes oversaturated with the products, consumer buying will reach new highs and the market itself will stop providing the VCR accessories at most mediums.

The cable and tv networks have already bent to this will, recognizing that in 20 years, no tvs will be Pan and Scan so if they want to syndicate shows on air right now, they will have to air them as their correct widescreen aspect ratio.

phillipej • Nov 02, 2006, 11:55pm •
I grant what you say, but I don't remember DVD players starting out at $2,000. Even at the current pricing level, a full HD system with cabling will set you back over $3,000. At that's not taking into account rebuilding your DVD collection nor upgrading your audio.

Even if I could go HD now, I wouldn't feel any urgency in upgrading my collection. After watching every standard DVD I own on a standard interlaced monitor, I'm going to be able to enjoy a bit of enhanced video (crisp resolution and anamorphic ws) without buying one HD disc.

1
Login to post a comment!