TV REVIEW- HEROES: The Eclipse Part 2 - Mania.com



TV Review of Heroes: The Eclipse Part 2

Mania Grade: B+

18 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • TV Series: Heroes
  • Episode: The Eclipse Part 2
  • Starring: Hayden Panettiere, Masi Oka, Ali Larter, Sendhil Ramamurthy, Milo Ventimiglia, Jack Coleman, Leonard Roberts, Greg Grunberg, Adrian Pasdar
  • Written By: Joe Pokaski, Aron Eli Coleite
  • Directed By: Holly Dale
  • Network: NBC
  • Series: Heroes

TV REVIEW- HEROES: The Eclipse Part 2

What Happens When the Heroes See the Light?

By Stephen Lackey     December 03, 2008


Sylar (Zachary Quinto) throws down some Darth Vader action on Noah (Jack Coleman) in this week’s episode of Heroes: The Eclipse Part 2(2008).
© NBC-Universal

 

As bad a character as Hiro has become, last week was still very much a return to form for Heroes. The focus was steady on the characters that matter and what happened to them had impact and really seemed to mean something. Now, there’s no way that a great deal of what was hinted at last week and actually happened this week wouldn’t be reversed when the eclipse ended but the evolution of the characters will stick around. This week continued with the same sort of precise and moderate pace as last week and that’s a good thing. The plot again doesn’t get bogged down by unimportant characters and side stories. Problems still remain, but even Hiro, the new Jar Jar Binks, had a really cool moment in this week’s episode.
 
For a while it seemed that Nathan and Peter’s mission to retrieve the Haitian was going to get drug down by a cheap D&D secondary mission but instead that mission started and finished in a matter of minutes. One of the lamest characters on the show, Nathan Petrelli, third to Hiro and Mohinder, kicked much butt with his flight ability. When the writers find ways to make invincibility and flight useful in a fight it can be some of the coolest scenes in the series. It’s easy to make flame blasts and lightening bolts useful in a fight and cool looking. Nathan ends up being one of the most problematic of the episode from a character basis. He started this thread of the story against his father but by the end of the episode he appears to be rejecting his mother and going back to his father. You could say that he’s playing the part of the waffling politician, but that just doesn’t feel right. He could also be planning to infiltrate his father’s gang but not telling his brother so one of his father’s minions won’t be able to read it from Peter’s mind at the most inopportune moments. If that were the case wouldn’t a mind reader pick up on that information from Nathan’s mind?
 
The reference to the missing 9th Wonder story was fantastic both as a nod to the hardcore comic book collector and a reference to a scene that could have easily been forgotten from the early days of the series. This leads to Hiro's awesome scene where he gets in the middle of a stand off between Bennett and Sylar. Speaking of Sylar, he’s finally back and more evil than ever. It took getting his throat cut and almost dying to make that happen, which is some very entertaining comic book melodrama. Hiro really has to grow up though. He could be a fun character again but he needs to be funny in a more mature way – maybe like Spider-man. The episode was full of thrills and a few twists (some were quite predictable though) and as previously mentioned it stayed focused on the characters that count. There was no Nikki/Tracy/Jessica this week and she wasn’t missed. No doubt she’ll play a more important part when Nathan returns to his father and his job. Tracy, Nathan, and Mohinder are easy targets for trimming the fat on this series.
 
Finally, it feels like Heroes is on the road to recovery, sort of like when a piece of metal is ripped from the base of the back of Claire’s head. It’s good to see Heroes finding its way back to being good again. Hopefully, it won’t stray from the path….

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 10 of 18
1 2 >  >>  
Kang 12/3/2008 3:56:56 AM

Heroes has gotten much better. I think Hiro is becoming the "Jar Jar Binks" of that operation. They need to tone down his child like antics. It is annoying.  They need to kill off that Hiro and bring back the future Hiro from season one. It is almost buffonish the way he behaves sometimes. They really need to tone that down.

kwsupes 12/3/2008 4:15:00 AM

I think it is messed up how everyone has been dogging on Heroes this  year. It was never a bad show, now true I think it has gotten better from previous weeks, but it never sucked. And what the heck is wrong with Hiro? I love his adventures wit Ando. I mean he is not as cool as Peter, but he is not supposed to be, Peter is the main character and greatest hero of them all. The show is getting back to form, but to me it may not have been as good, but it was still better than most shows out there. I think one person six months ago started griping and everyone else was bored so they decided to gripe as well.

Kang 12/3/2008 4:17:36 AM

I also think that they need to have the cheerleader come to terms with her abilities and stop whining.  The Hiro thing really bothers me. Why does the Asian guy have to be this childlike idiot who has cool powers. Its like  if  Sulu was  doing laundry on the Enterprise. Roddenberry saw to his credit that racial stereotypes were wrong. Its ridiculous how Hiro behaves. They need to make him grow up. I like Elle. Why did they kill off Elle after she screws Sylar?

Hobbs 12/3/2008 6:38:53 AM

supes, it was never a bad show in the first season but it has sucked since then.  Ratings reflect it, the fact they just fired the head guys from the show proves it.  It will probably make it to a 4th season but it won't last past that unless they get their act together.

They have a huge chance to change things around with the eclipse episode and weed out some characters and define others...yet it doesn't look like they did any of that.

I think the review is more wishful thinking cause it's not even close to recovery.  You might see a recover towards the end of the sseason when the new head guys influence starts to take over but otherwise this show is still shit. 

Myrdinn 12/3/2008 6:40:42 AM

Hrm. Is Elle dead? Maybe Syler just fixed her brain.

(abortive edit that ate my post) Reason: he gave that little speach about being broken, and Future Glasses Syler mentioned his power is about seeing how things work, are broken, and how to fix them. Little Future Noah has to come from somewhere and is blonde: Elle solves this. This is assuming that LFN isn't a retoaged HRG, and not Claire's kid. Hiro: Hiro was close to Future Hiro at the ends of both of the previous seasons. It is about darn time he grows up in more than just the mental aspect.
fft5305 12/3/2008 8:29:38 AM

Good call on Elle/Sylar Myrdinn. That didn't even occur to me, but it makes sense. I thought it made no sense for him to start killing again when he had just been shown how to take powers without killing.

Hobbs, I have to disagree that ratings bombs and writer firing prove that a show sucks. Many good shows fail while 2 1/2 Men stays in the Top 10 every week. The firing was just a knee-jerk reaction made to appease fans. It's like when the Eagels yanked McNabb after one bad half of football.

I hope Hiro gets his brain fixed. It's fine to have him age 10 for comic relief, but it will get old pretty quickly. Same with Powerless Peter.  I think the way to go with Peter is to have him regain his original ability to absorb other people's powers, but not get back all the powers he previously absorbed. That way, he'd have to regain any new powers and we won't be all-powerful. Maybe he can even just absorb powers temporarily, like Rogue, then as he uses his powers and grows, he can keep them longer.

hanso 12/3/2008 8:39:03 AM

I'm sorry Heroes, I'm sorry for the hate.  I've completely misunderstood you.  Your not a superhero drama, no no no.  You are a comedy.   It's comedic gold people!!!!!!!!  I don't know why NBC doesn't pair it up with The Office & 30 Rock.  As a comedy you work 10x better.

HRG is mad, Sylar & Elle have messed up his daughter.  He goes out and gets himself a sniper rifle for revenge.  Then he has them in sight, ready for the kill and get his revenge.  But wait, HRG doesn't do anything, you see Sylar & Elle are making out and will have the no pants dance.  HRG decides to watch first. lol  You see HRG is a perv!!  Beautiful i tell ya, comedic gold!!!!!

Hobbs 12/3/2008 9:33:14 AM

fft,  see hanso's comments.  I take it back, he's right.  The show doesn't suck as long as you watch it as a comedy.  Your Mcnabb comparsion is way off.  They didn't fire the head guys to appease the fans, they did it to KEEP the fans so they don't have to cancel a show they put a shit load of money into advertising for.  And 2 and 1/2 men is way better than Heroes....right now anyways.

I hope they can turn this show around...so far they are failing in a very bad way so in the meantime.....

BRING BACK THE 4400, they did the super hero thing right! 

I didn't even think about that hanso until you pointed it out...he did have them in his sites before they did the nasty but waited....

Just another HUGE problem with this show.  Time to give it the boot!!

 

Long live the 4400!!!

evilbeagle 12/3/2008 10:51:43 AM

I liked this episode a lot.  They were smart to begin referencing the first season and trying to get back to their roots.  Hiro needs to become the badass time traveller from the first season.  Lose the juvenile stuff.

His scene in this show was cool though.  I dug it.  It's not meant to be oscar worthy for god's sake, but they're on the right track for recovery.

redhairs99 12/3/2008 12:52:29 PM

I was wondering the same thing when I saw this episode.  The last one ended with Noah having Sylar and Elle in the sniper scope and this week, they apparently had time to make sweet, sweet love down by the fire?  Noah must be a perve if he waited the 3 minutes that must have taken.

On the Hiro issue, I think the future scene were Ando kills Hiro needs to happen and soon.  I've never understood why so many people have thought so highly of Hiro.  I've always found his character annoying as hell.  I do like Ando though and future bad-ass Hiro, but I've just never cared for nerdy, child-like Hiro.  Oh well, everyone's intitled to have their own opinions I guess.

1 2 >  >>  

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS