ULTIMATE X #1 Review - Mania.com



Comics Opinion

Mania Grade: B-

4 Comments | Add

 

Rate & Share:

 

Related Links:

 

Info:

  • Title: Ultimate X #1
  • Writer: Jeph Loeb
  • Pencils: Arthur Adams
  • Colorist: Aspen MLT’s Peter Steigerwald
  • Digital Inks: Aspen MLT’s Mark Roslan
  • Letters: Richard Starkings & Comicraft’s Albert Deschesne
  • Publisher: Marvel Comics
  • Publication Date: February 3, 2010
  • Price: $3.99
  • Series:

ULTIMATE X #1 Review

"Perhaps the Ultimate Universe is starting to realize its potential here"

By Chad Derdowski     February 05, 2010
Source: Mania


ULTIMATE X #1 Review
© Marvel Entertainment

Well, well, well… turns out a baby was dropped off on the doorstep of one James Hudson a few years back by an old Army buddy by the name of James Howlett who most folks knew as Logan, or maybe Wolverine. Never mind who the mother was – that kid is definitely his father’s son, right down to his fingernails… or claws.

And that, in a nutshell is how Ultimate X opens up. We’ve got a few familiar names and a teenager who is something of a rebel without a cause. After a drag racing accident leaves him in a position that most folks don’t walk away from, Jimmy Hudson discovers that he heals a lot quicker than most folks. When Kitty Pryde shows up at his doorstep with a box of Wolverine’s possessions and a holographic projector, he finds out the reasons why. He also gets a pep talk from his old man (both of ‘em, actually) and by the end of the issue, it looks like this rebel might just have found himself something worth fightin’ for.

I’ve always felt that the Ultimate Universe had limitless potential that was just being wasted. They started a brand spankin’ new Marvel U from scratch, unhindered by years of continuity and what did they do? They introduced Ultimatized versions of everyone from Longshot to Ronin to Willie Lumpkin. It wasn’t interesting, it just felt like “Hey, let’s take this clean slate and bog it down with a bunch of crap from the regular Marvel U!” And then along came Ultimatum, which saw countless heroes die including some pretty heavy hitters. Well, that got me interested. And now Ultimate X is here and we’ve got a new generation of X-Men in the works. It’s cool to see an alternate universe in which anything can happen and now it finally does.

But honestly… they had me at Arthur Adams.

There’s not much in the way of action here; the whole thing is something of a quiet character study with a few super powers mixed in. We get an exploration of who Wolverine was as seen through the eyes of one of his best friends, and a look at how the world views mutantkind post-Ultimatum. We get to know this universes’ version of the Hudson’s and the type of folks they are as well as the type of kid they raised: and apparently Jeph Loeb feels that nature often wins out over nurture. The kid might’ve been raised by two decent, hardworking parents, but he just has too much of his father in him. Hell, he’s even got that stupid haircut.

Cover art to ULTIMATE X #1 by Arthur Adams

I enjoyed it. It was all pretty set-uppy but it kept me entertained for 22 pages. I really enjoyed the slow pace of Loeb’s (James Hudson’s) narration and it’s always a treat to see the work of Mr. Arthur Adams, though I don’t feel this is his best work. Some of the younger characters alternate between looking too soft and deformed, like gingerbread men who weren’t left in the oven long enough, to being too skinny and sinewy, like fleshy skeletons. It isn’t Art Adams of the ‘80s, but it’s always cool to see him, and especially on an X-book.

I also got a real kick out of seeing the Ultimate Universe start to take some risks. You’re not tied down to 70 years of continuity… live it up! Kill Wolverine, split up the Fantastic Four, make the Red Skull Captain America’s son! You don’t have to sell pillowcases or t-shirts, so just cut loose and have a blast! While this book wasn’t exactly Loeb and Adams cutting loose, there was a great deal of groundwork being laid. Frankly, the team depicted on the cover does nothing for me, but the issue was solid enough that I’ll probably check out the next issue or two just to see what it’s all about. I’m giving it a B-. It might’ve gotten a B, but the $3.99 price tag knocks it down a peg. Sorry, it was a good book, but it was not four dollars good. So B- it is.

COMMENTS AND RESPONSES

Showing items 1 - 4 of 4
1 
jedibanner 2/5/2010 5:42:29 AM

I have to admit i was surprise by this issue. I got it only and specifically, only for Mr. Adams's drawing and nothing else....then I got surprised.

Knowing Mr. Loeb was writting this, i expected less then nothing. NOw...I can honestly say either he was reprimended or he took a step back but, his writting was a bit better, the story made sense and no non-sense of big mysteries or crazy events happenbing al of a sudden without any explenations.

That's the problem with this book is that, in my view Red Hulk has had such a negative impact on Loeb's capabilities of writting good stories that now, my reflex reading his stuff is to expect crazy things happening without explenations.

This time for the first issue Loeb's writting seemed simpler, no larger mystery involved helps the story to go forward and it's a good read.

Good review Chad.

ChadDerdowski 2/5/2010 6:57:34 AM

Thanks, man.

It's a shame that Loeb has put such a tarnish on his reputation lately.  This book proves that he can still be a fine writer when puts his mind to it, but the "everything and the kitchen sink" approach he often takes doesn't always work, as Red Hulk has proven.

I was pretty surprised by this issue as well.  I'll admit that my reflex reaction to anything with an X in the title is probably pretty similar to your reaction to the name Loeb - I just assume it's going to suck.  But not so in this case!  I'm interested to see how this first arc plays out... and either way, putting Art Adams on the book is a good way to get me to buy it.

DarthDuck 2/5/2010 8:23:09 AM

I join you both as someone who was very surprised by this issue.  I've always liked the Ultimate U but also felt that Ultimatum was completely necessary .  I've been enjoying Ultimate Avengers and even though Ultimate Spider-Man has always been great it certainly has new life right now.  And now this.  I hope it continues to be good and while I know Loeb can be, well Loeb, I like the overall direction of the Ultimate U and look forward to more.

Was surprised you didn't have a comment on the claws, one way or another.   I liked it actually, better than bone claws and certainly better than a long drawn out ordeal of him getting them implanted.  He's got them, we're done and we're moving.  I actually like that.

gauleyboy420 2/5/2010 12:22:11 PM

I've been a fan of the Ultimate U since it started... I've enjoyed the re-imagining , until it got bogged down and started becoming the same as the Regular U, 616 right? Anyway the point I started not caring about Ultimate X-Men was when Strife was introduced... too many characters.

LOVED Ulitmates 1&2, BUT LOEB STUNK UP #3... THANK GOD Millar is back on Ultimate Avengers


I liked Ultimatum, I know a lot of folks didn't but maybe it was just that they actually killed main characters, it suddenly got more fresh, what it used to be.

I used to love Jeph Loeb's work (especially his collaborations with Tim Sale), but after the tragic death of his son, His work really suffered... couldn't read ANY of it.

I bought Rulk for the same reason I'll buy this The ARTIST! Frank Cho, and ESPECIALLY ART ADAMS were the reason I bought Red Hulk, as soon as they left I stopped buying it, the story stunk.

I will buy this but only because I too wanna see Art Adams on an X-Book again... I don't expect much from the story, but this review gives me a little hope...

1 

ADD A COMMENT

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Please click here to login.

POPULAR TOPICS