Comic Review
8 Comments | Add a Comment

1


Uncanny X-Men #495

By: Kurt Amacker, Columnist
Date: Thursday, February 14, 2008

This 495th issue of Uncanny X-Men introduces readers to the world of Marvel’s Merry Mutants after the events of Messiah Complex. In short, with Charles Xavier absent – though likely not dead – Scott Summers struggles to redefine the team and lead in his mentor’s absence. His first order of business is to lie to Tony Stark about the existence of the X-Men, telling the Iron Man and S.H.I.E.L.D. director that the team has disbanded. Stark, of course, wants the team to cooperate with the Superhuman Registration Act (SRA). But, Summers points out an obvious, gaping question about the SRA – should you force someone born with powers to register, even if they don’t act as vigilantes? Stark leaves without answering the question, but Summers confides to Emma Frost that the team will continue to operate. He just doesn’t know what to do with them. All the while, Nightcrawler, Colossus, and Wolverine are road-tripping to Russia, and causing no small amount of mischief on the way. Logan gets in bar fights and hacks Nightcrawler’s image inducer to make him look like Angelina Jolie, thus leading to an unexpected tabloid appearance. But, the real story comes when Angel lands in San Francisco and discovers a neighborhood that may still be literally stuck in the 1960s. Adventure awaits, I’m sure.

Ed Brubaker’s decompression really makes the story a bit thin. It’s a fun read, but not a lot happens other than an introduction to the post-MC world, complete with corrective revelations. This probably could’ve taken up half the page count and included more about the mysterious neighborhood Angel discovers, rather than more images of Emma and Scott frolicking in the Savage Land. Everyone likes to see Emma, but we should all know by now that she’s not getting naked. More story and less fun in the sun, please. Regardless, Brandon Choi and Sonia Oback work miracles on the issue’s art, making this one of the best looking superhero comics I’ve seen in quite some time. This is as good or better than Steve McNiven’s work on Civil War. Despite the somewhat decompressed story, this 495th issue of Uncanny X-Men is never less than a pleasure to look at.

New readers should probably take this opportunity to jump on with the mutants. This isn’t the best single issue I’ve ever read by a long shot, but it serves as an agreeable introduction to the X-Men following Messiah Complex

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@mania.com.



Related Products
Comments/Responses
1
Merin • Feb 13, 2008, 10:41pm •
I'll comment with my take on the issue - the review I posted about a week ago - http://www.mania.com/member-reviews/0/312.html

lister • Feb 14, 2008, 09:09am •
Kinda with Merin on this. Liked (but not loved) the story (I am spoiled by Astonishing, I think). Did not care for the art.

As to the story, perhaps, as Kurt says, it was a bit too much introduction, not enough throughput.

SaintDemon • Feb 14, 2008, 09:34am •
I haven't read the issue but somebody at Marvel commented that Xavier is not dead and will be helping to lead the "New" X-Men or something like that.

Also a friend pointed out they have to paralyze Xavier first before they can kill him.

muchdrama • Feb 14, 2008, 03:20pm •
a) Brubaker can't write the X-Men worth shit (which is fascinating, considering how well he writes Captain America).

b) Brandon Choi is one truly awful artist.

Merin • Feb 14, 2008, 04:51pm •
To elaborate a little:

I feel that Brubaker has a good "feel" for most of the characters (his Emma seems off, but to be honest all Emma's since Gen X was cancelled feel wrong to me) but he can't write them.

If you can understand the difference I'm getting at. What he has the characters doing, how he has them acting, their motivations - he's pretty close to right on. Better than Morrison or Carey or Kyle or Yost, but not quite as good as Whedon or Claremont.

No, the X-Men are at a floating point. Things had gotten better, but not yet great, and we are just about to slide down to bad again.

Scott creating X-Force is such a 24 thing to do, such a Dick Cheney move. Such a post-Civil War comic book change. But Brubaker didn't have much to do with that, from what I can tell.

I'm am confused to see Wolverine laying low with the New Avengers whilst in Germany and Russia with Piotr and Kurt whilst running around killing with X-Force. There must be more clones than Laura.

Moz72 • Feb 14, 2008, 04:52pm •
I'm satisfied just looking at White Witch on the cover!

lister • Feb 15, 2008, 08:34am •
I'd rather look at real porn than cartoon porn.

Merin • Feb 16, 2008, 05:29pm •
#6

White Witch is a DC character from the Legion of Super-Heroes.

The woman on the cover of UXM #495 is Emma Frost, formerly known as the White Queen.

1
Login to post a comment!