I wouldn't have a problem with Hamm as Supes or Batman for that matter. Hell, Don Draper is only baby steps from being Bruce Wayne anyways. They kind of acknowledged that in the first episode, I think.
With that said, I could also go for a return of Routh. I felt the same way I felt about Clooney as Batman; if he had been given a better script with a director who actually understood what a good Batman (or in Routh's case, Superman) movie should be, he would have done a great job.
But, I have to be honest, I'm rooting for Welling. Let the next Superman movie pick up where Smallville leaves off. With a good director, great script and a real budget, this would be huge.
Samson










"So where the hell has this guy been for the last 15 years? He's had these powers to change/help the world and he waited until he was in his 40s to start helping the Earth? FTW?!"
The answer to that is simple my friend, he was busy running an ad agency, drinking, smoking and banging chics left and right. Now its time to be Supes.