Comic Review


WOLVERINE: FIRST CLASS #1

By: Kurt Amacker
Review Date: Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Wolverine: First Class #1 achieves that rare balance between nostalgia and all-ages thrills in a lighthearted short story. Marvel milks the X-Men for nostalgia value an awful lot lately, with an unusual amount of stories set in the team’s past. In this case, writer Fred Van Lente shows veteran X-Man Wolverine and newcomer Kitty Pryde on their first mission together. In this issue, Kitty Pryde narrates in her journal, typed in the appropriately 1980s computer in her dorm room at the Xavier School for Gifted Youngsters. She describes her excitement at attending the school, but wonders about Logan. Despite the usually positive atmosphere on campurs, the gruff Canadian mutant keeps to himself and rarely smiles. Professor Charles Xavier sends the two on a mission together to locate a powerful mutant presence in a town in West Virginia. Needless to say, Logan cares very little for this. Kitty is excited to finally see action, but her efforts to warm up to her partner are only marginally successful. It is only when the two realize that their “mutant presence” has thrown an entire town into a panic that they must work together.

This issue stands about as far from “grim and gritty” as you can get. No one dies, no one is raped, Wolverine’s troubled psyche is only touched upon, and everyone’s friends by the end. First Class #1 reminds you of reading comics as a kid, when superheroes provoked a sense of awe and wonder, with just enough humanity to keep them relatable. Laura Villari’s colors shine brightly from Andrea Di Vito’s crisp, appropriately exaggerated art. Though essentially a children’s story, this issue maintains a tone of youthful optimism to which anyone with a heart can relate. “All Ages” doesn’t have to mean “Strictly for Kids.” And, while children will certainly enjoy this, adults will likely be reminded of their earliest experiences with the X-Men. 

The only real problem with this book is that in its effort to maintain that incredibly positive tone, it softens the edges a bit too much. The real culprit in the West Virginia town turns out to be more of a misunderstanding than anything else. The X-Men have always fought ignorance, and the ignorance in play here comes off as less of a threat than an accident. Though the story certainly wouldn’t improve with Wolverine decapitating angry townspeople, one hopes that stories aimed at children could acknowledge the reality of bigotry in the world. Then again, most prejudice results from misunderstanding of one kind or another, so perhaps this is more appropriate than it appears. Still, people are rarely short of reasons to hate one another. Denying culpability in favor of a more science-fiction explanation seems unnecessary. 

This first issue of Wolverine: First Class hearkens back to a gentler time in the history of Marvel Comics. It’s just the kind of thing kids should start with, and it will remind adults of those summer days spent rereading stacks of back issues under a tree. It comes off as a bit naïve, but it’s still a lot of fun. Pick this one up.

Questions? Comments? Let us know what you think at comicscape@mania.com.



More Content By Kurt Amacker
Comments/Responses
1 2 > >>
bernini • Mar 31, 2008, 10:28pm •
yeah, nothing says "softer" and "gentler" than a homicidal maniac with 12-inch razors poppin' outta the back of his hands for the sole purpose of engaging in a dialogue with his opponents that usually ends in their disembowelment. Gee, Marvel, I feel soft and cuddly *all over!*

WISEGUY562 • Mar 31, 2008, 10:50pm •
I was going to skip this but now I may go out and get a copy. I like the feeling of nostalgia.
I remember when Wolverine was my favorite character (before he was headlining his own series), but right now we get way too much of him. Not only does he have 3 ongoing with this one, he also has a current mini and he appears in no less than 3 team books(U.X-Men,X-Force and New Avengers). I think Marvel needs to step back and reduce his visibility a bit before we get burned out with him.

AzuLTaLoN • Mar 31, 2008, 11:24pm •
yeah wiseguy i was saying the same thing a few weeks ago when logan #1 hit stores, marvel is gonna shove wolvie down our throats at least till the movie comes out and then they will probably shove wolvie harder and deeper down our throats and more again when the dvd comes out and again and again and again cause queffsada just doesn't let up. someone needs to give me a job so i can save some money and hire a hitman to spray queffsadas brains all over the walls of marvel!

Merin • Apr 01, 2008, 07:59am •
Bought it and really enjoyed it.

Kurt calls it the "gentler" times - I say it's back to a more entertaining time of self-contained stories and more colors than black, gray, and charcoal.

This book is about a B+, certainly. Anyone who pays any attention to me knows that Wolverine is not on my list of characters I like to read about. But with how much I like X-Men First Class, I thought I'd give this a go. Young Kitty was always a joy to read, and if they could capture a small portion of the magic Claremont had in the X-Men book back at this time period (when Kitty was new to the team) then I knew it would be worth my read.

I enjoyed this book. Not the best Wolverine I've read, but the story was good and I enjoyed the art. That's about all I ask of a comic - good story, good art.

lister • Apr 01, 2008, 08:54am •
Is it 616-compliant?

WISEGUY562 • Apr 01, 2008, 11:16am •
I think it's safe to assume that if it doesn't say What If, Ultimate or something hinting at an imaginary tale that it is 616. But like a lot of tales of the past there always seems to be some revisionism.

lister • Apr 01, 2008, 11:49am •
I thought that "X-Men: First Class" was outside regular continuity, so I would have assumed the same for this. But the review makes it sound 616-ish.

WISEGUY562 • Apr 02, 2008, 08:21am •
Actually, First Class is 616. But like they do with any property that ages they updated. So technically these are untold stories, but the era obviously has been brought up, otherwise we'd have to say the X-Men are in their 50's. By updating the era it also lets today's youngsters relate. The writer said the main reason he changed the costumes a bit was also so long time readers can know that these are not re-prints.

lister • Apr 02, 2008, 08:58am •
Thanks for the clarifications WG562. Sooooo... X-M-FC sounds kinda like a retcon (sorta like different Gospels of the Bible) while this sounds like it slips into the "real" or the retconned continuity. Is that a fair assessment?

WISEGUY562 • Apr 02, 2008, 05:16pm •
I'd agree with that assessment completely.

1 2 > >>
Login to post a comment!